Bohai burials in China: general characteristics and funeral rite
https://doi.org/10.21285/2415-8739-2023-4-73-92
EDN: HMLMMX
- Р Р‡.МессенРТвЂВВВВВВВВжер
- РћРТвЂВВВВВВВВнокласснРСвЂВВВВВВВВРєРСвЂВВВВВВВВ
- LiveJournal
- Telegram
- ВКонтакте
- РЎРєРѕРїРСвЂВВВВВВВВровать ссылку
Full Text:
Abstract
More than twenty Bohai cemeteries have been discovered in China, and almost a thousand of burials have been researched. A significant number of excavated burials allows us to consider in sufficient detail and comprehensively their general characteristics. They usually consist of a grave pit and a mound, based on building materials and forms, can be divided into 3 groups and 6 types, according to the research of Vei Tsun’chen; sometimes grave structures were built on the mounds, which differ in size and design. Most of the burials are in the valleys of four basins of large rivers (five districts), in which they are concentrated and have obvious regional characteristic, which show the process of development of Bohai burials and features of different stages. Funeral traditions of Bohai are also different. Different cultures influenced the development of forms and traditions of Bohai burials, at first the influence of Mohe cultural was prevailed, and the features of Goguryeo and other local cultures are also obvious, with the development of the state, the influence of Tang dynasty became stronger. The characteristics of burials of different ranks are different. The graves of members of the royal house and the aristocracy are important objects of Bohai studies in China, changes of their location, layout and shape show not only the development of culture, but also the political conjuncture of Bohai state. The distribution structure of the Bohai cemeteries and other sites help to consider the process of changes in the administrative division system and political circumstances of Bohai State.
Keywords
About the Author
Yumeng HeRussian Federation
He Yumeng
Doctoral candidate, Department of Early Medieval Archaeology
89, Pushkinskaya St., Vladivostok 690001
References
1. Ivliev A.L. Issledovanie bokhaiskikh pogrebenii v Severo-Vostochnom Kitae (po materialam stat'i Chzhen Yunchzhenya) // Novye materialy po srednevekovoi arkheologii Dal'nego Vostoka SSSR. Vladivostok : DVO AN SSSR, 1989. S. 12-25.
2. Stoyakin M.A. Ostatki zhivotnykh s bokhaiskikh pamyatnikov v Kitae: ispol'zovanie zhivotnykh v povsednevnoi zhizni i pogrebal'noi praktike // Rossiya i ATR. 2020. (4). S. 175-187. https://doi.org/10.24411/1026-8804-2020-10058. EDN: AIRRVX.
3. Bai Myao, Li Tsyan. «Domiki nad pogrebeniyami» Udi i nadmogil'nye sooruzheniya Bokhaya - s obsuzhdeniem nasypei nad pogrebeniyami Kogure // Sbornik k 70-letiyu gospodina Vei Sun'chena. Pekin : Nauka, 2015. C. 306-316
4. Van Sya. Pogrebeniya printsess Chzhen'-syao i Chzhen'khuei // Ucheba i issledovanie (Syuesi yui tan'so). 1985. (4). C. 138-143 = 王侠. 贞惠公主墓与贞孝公主墓. 学习与探索, 1985. (4): 138-143.
5. Van Tszyan'tsyun'. O stele na pogrebenii bokhaiskoi printsessy Chzhen'-khuei // Ven' u tszikan'. Pekin : Izd-vo Ven' U chuban'she, 1980. C. 208-216 = 王健群. 渤海贞惠公主墓碑考. 文物集刊. 北京: 文物出版社. 1980. C. 208-216.
6. Van Chzhigan, Chzhan Syuzhun, Lin' Shisyan. Dve idei o bokhaiskom mavzolee Chzhen'lin' // Istoriya i geografiya Severo-vostoka (Dun bei shi di). 2009. (4). S. 35-38. = 王志刚, 张秀荣, 林世香. 关于渤海“珍陵”的两点认识. 东北史地, 2009. (4). 35-38.
7. Van Chzhigan. Arkheologicheskoe ob"yasnenie o «domikakh nad pogrebeniyami» - izuchenie bokhaiskikh nadmogil'nykh sooruzhenii // Arkheologiya (Kaogu). 2014. (6). C. 78-91 = 王志刚. “冢上作屋”的考古学诠释--渤海墓上建筑研究.
8. Van Chzhigan. «Domiki nad pogrebeniyami» i zhertvoprinoshenie pered pogrebeniyami - Izuchenie bokhaiskikh podkhodov k zhertvoprinosheniyam // Sbornik k 70-letiyu gospodina Vei Sun'chena. Pekin : Nauka, 2015. C. 317-324 =王志刚. 冢上作屋与墓前祭祀--渤海墓祭方式研究. 庆祝魏存成先生七十岁论文集. 北京: 科学出版社, 2015. C. 317-324.
9. Van Chenli, Tsao Chzhenzhun. Drevnii bokhaiskii mogil'nik Lyudinshan' v uezde Dun'khua provintsii Tszilin' //Arkheologiya (Kaogu). 1961. (6). S. 298-301 = 王承礼, 曹正榕. 吉林敦化六顶山渤海古墓. 考古, 1961. (6). C. 298-301.
10. Van Chenli. Zapisi ob issledovanii bokhaiskikh pogrebenii Lyudinshan' goroda Dun'khua // Social Science Front (Shekhuei kesyue chzhan'syan'). 1979. (3). S. 200-210 = 王承礼. 敦化六顶山渤海古墓清理发掘记. 社会科学战线. 1979. (3). C. 200-210.
11. Van Chenli. Sravnitel'noe izuchenie nadpisei stel na pogrebeniyakh bokhaiskikh printsess Chzhen'-khuei i Chzhen'syao tanskogo perioda // Front sotsial'noi nauki (Shekhuei kesyue chzhan'syan'). 1982. (3). S. 181-187 = 王承礼. 唐代渤海<贞惠公主墓志>和<贞孝公主墓志>的比较研究. 社会科学战线, 1982. (3). C. 181-187.
12. Van Chenli. Izuchenie teksta stely na pogrebenii printsessy Chzhen'-syao bokhaiskogo gosudarstva tanskogo perioda (I) // Muzeinye issledovaniya (Bouguan' yan'tszyu). 1984a. (2). C. 40-49 = 王承礼. 唐代渤海国“贞孝公主墓志”研究 (上). 博物馆研究. 1984a. (2). C. 40-49.
13. Van Chenli. Izuchenie teksta stely na pogrebenii printsessy Chzhen'-syao bokhaiskogo gosudarstva tanskogo perioda (II) // Muzeinye issledovaniya (Bouguan' yan'tszyu). 1984b. (3). C. 28-36 = 王承礼. 唐代渤海国“贞孝公主墓志”研究 (中). 博物馆研究. 1984b. (3). C. 28-36.
14. Van Chenli. Izuchenie teksta stely na pogrebenii printsessy Chzhen'-syao bokhaiskogo gosudarstva v tanskogo perioda (III) // Muzeinye issledovaniya (Bouguan' yan'tszyu). 1985. (1). C. 55-64 = 王承礼. 唐代渤海国“贞孝公主墓志”研究 (下). 博物馆研究. 1985. (1). C. 55-64.
15. Vei Tsun'chen. Bokhaiskie pogrebeniya chlenov korolevskogo doma i aristokratii // Sbornik sochinenii tret'ego godovogo sobraniya Arkheologicheskogo obshchestva Kitaya. Pekin : Izd-vo Ven' u chuban'she. 1981. C. 258-264 = 魏存成. 渤海王室贵族墓葬. 中国考古学年会第三次会议年会论文集. 北京: 文物出版社, 1981. C. 258-264.
16. Vei Tsun'chen. Arkheologiya Bokhaya. Pekin : Izd-vo Ven' U chuban'she. 2008a. 309 c. = 魏存成. 渤海考古. 北京: 文物出版社, 2008a. 309 s.
17. Vei Tsun'chen. Obshchii obraz i glavnye kharakteristiki bokhaiskikh pogrebenii // Istoriya i geografiya SeveroVostoka (Dunbei shidi). 2008b. (4). C. 15-19 = 魏存成. 渤海墓葬的整体面貌和主要特征. 东北史地. 2008. (4). C. 15-19.
18. Vei Tsun'chen. Evolyutsiya bokhaiskikh pogrebenii i natsional'nye sostavy naseleniya v rannem periode Bokhaya // Vestnik obshchestvennykh nauk Tszilin'skogo universiteta. 2014. (2). C. 122-128 = 魏存成. 渤海墓葬演变与渤海初期人口的民族构成. 吉林大学社会科学学报. 2014. (2). C. 122-128.
19. Vei Tsun'chen. Eshche raz o voprosakh, svyazannykh s pogrebeniyami chlenov korolevskogo doma i aristokratii // Sbornik sochinenii arkheologii Kogure i Bokhaya. Pekin : Izd-vo Ven' u chuban'she. 2015. C. 391-400 = 魏存成. 渤海王室贵族墓葬及相关问题再探讨. 高句丽渤海考古论集. 北京:科学出版社, 2015. C. 391-400.
20. Institut arkheologii Kitaiskoi akademii obshchestvennykh nauk. Lyudinshan' i Bokhaichzhen'. Pekin : Izd-vo bol'shaya entsiklopediya Kitaya (Chzhungo dabaike tsyuan'shu chuban'she), 1997. 268 c. = 中国社会科学院考古研究所. 六顶山与渤海镇: 唐代渤海国的贵族墓地与都城遗址. 北京:中国大百科全书出版社, 1997. 268 s.
21. Institut kul'turnykh tsennostei i arkheologii provintsii Kheiluntszyan. Otchet ob issledovanii bokhaiskogo mogil'nika na territorii Khuntszun'yuichan g. Nin"an' s 1992 g. po 1995 g. Pekin : Izd-vo Ven' U chuban'she. 2009. 548 c. = 黑龙江省文物考古研究所. 宁安虹鳟鱼场: 19921995年度渤海墓地考古发掘报告. 北京: 文物出版社, 2009, 548 s.
22. Institut kul'turnykh tsennostei i arkheologii provintsii Tszilin', Kabinet komiteta upravleniya kul'turnym naslediem Yan'byan'skogo koreiskogo natsional'nogo avtonomnogo okruga. Kratkii otchet ob issledovanii bokhaiskogo mogil'nika chlenov korolevskogo doma Lunkhai v g. Khelun provintsii Tszilin' // Arkheologiya (Kaogu). 2009. (6). C. 23-39 = 吉林省文物考古研究所, 延边朝鲜族自治州文物管理委员会办公室. 吉林和龙市龙海渤海王室墓葬发掘简报. 2009. (6). C. 23-39.
23. Institut kul'turnykh tsennostei i arkheologii provintsii Tszilin', Upravlenie kul'turnym naslediem g. Dun'khua. Otchet ob issledovanii bokhaiskogo mogil'nika Lyudinshan' s 2004 g. po 2009 g. Pekin : Izd-vo Ven' U chuban'she. 2012. 219 c. = 吉林省文物考古研究所, 敦化市文物管理所. 六顶山渤海墓葬: 2004 2009年清理发掘报告. 北京: 文物出版社, 2012. 219 C.
24. Komitet po upravleniyu pamyatnikami kul'tury Yan'byan'skogo koreiskogo natsional'nogo avtonomnogo okruga, Natsional'nyi kraevedcheskii muzei Yan'byan'skogo koreiskogo natsional'nogo avtonomnogo okruga. Bokhaiskoe pogrebenie v sele Lunkhu uezda Khelun provintsii Tszilin' // Issledovanie muzeya (Bouguan' yan'tszyu). 1993. (1). C. 73-78 = 延边朝鲜族自治州文物管理委员会, 延边朝鲜族自治州博物馆. 吉林省和龙龙湖渤海墓葬. 博物馆研究, 1993. (1). C. 73-78.
25. Li Dyan'fu. Sravnitel'noe izuchenie fresok v pogrebenii bokhaiskoi printsessy Chzhen'-syao tanskogo perioda i v pogrebeniyakh Kogure // Pamyatniki kul'tury Kheiluntszyana (Kheiluntszyan ven'u tsunkan'). 1983. (2). C. 38-42 =李殿福. 唐代渤海贞孝公主墓壁画与高句丽壁画比较研究.黑龙江文物丛刊, 1983. (2). C. 38-42.
26. Li Tsyan. Znakomstvo s «domikami nad pogrebeniyami» Udi i Bokhaya, Sbornik Sin'goudi k 70-letiyu gospodina Lin' Yun' // Pekin : Nauka, 2008. C. 543-548 = 李强. 勿吉与渤海冢上作屋初识. 新果集--庆祝林沄先生七十华诞论文集. 北京: 科学出版社. 2008. C. 543-548.
27. Li Shulei. Eshche raz ob evolyutsiyakh form bokhaiskikh pogrebenii // Pamyatniki kul'tury severa (Beifan ven'u). 2005. (1). C. 35-45 = 李蜀蕾. 渤海墓葬类型演变再探讨. 北方文物, 2005. (1). C. 35-45. https://doi.org/10.16422/j.cnki.1001-0483.2005.01.007.
28. Lo Tszitszu. Stely bokhaiskikh printsess Chzhen'-khuei i Chzhen'-syao // Issledovanie muzeya (Bouguan' yan'tszyu). 1983. (3). C. 38 = 罗继祖. 渤海贞惠贞孝两公主的墓碑. 博物馆研究, 1983. (3). C. 38.
29. Lyu Syaodun. Voprosy, svyazannye s mavzoleyami bokhaiskikh korolev i sootvetstvuyushchimi voprosami // Sbornik k 70-letiyu gospodina Chzhan Chzhunpei. Pekin : Nauka (Kesyue chuban'she). 2004. C. 538-548 = 刘晓东. 渤海王陵及相关问题. 庆祝张忠培先生七十岁论文集. 北京: 科学出版社. 2004. C. 538-548.
30. Lyu Syaodun. Prodolzhenie obsuzhdeniya voprosov, svyazannykh s mavzoleyami bokhaiskikh korolev // Pamyatniki kul'tury severa (Beifan ven'u). 2012. (3). S. 40-49 = 刘晓东. 渤海王陵及相关问题续论. 北方文物, 2012. (3). C. 40-49. https://doi.org/10.16422/j.cnki.1001-0483.2012.03.005. Lyu Syaodun. Eshche raz o teme bokhaiskogo mavzoleya
31. Chzhen'lin' - k 50-letiyu so dnya gibeli gospodina Tszin' Yufu // Pamyatniki kul'tury severa (Beifan ven'u). 2013. (3). S. 36-42 = 刘晓东. 渤海“珍陵”问题的再探讨--纪念金毓黻先生逝世 50 周年. 北方文物, 2013. (3). C. 36-42. https://doi.org/10.16422/j.cnki.1001-0483.2013.03.022.
32. Lyu Syaodun. Dopolnitel'nye zamechaniya o datirovke nachala stroitel'stva khramov № 8 i №. 9 za severnym valom Verkhnei stolitsy Bokhaya // Izuchenie arkheologii v prigranichnom raione. Pekin : Nauka (Kesyue chuban'she), 2019. Vyp. 25. C. 383-393 = 刘晓东. 关于渤海上京城北垣外侧 8、9 号寺庙址始建年代的补充说明. 边疆考古研究 (第25辑). 北京: 科学出版社. 2019. C. 383-393.
33. Lyu Syaodun. Klassifikatsiya form bokhaiskikh pogrebenii i ikh evolyutsiya // Pamyatniki kul'tury severa (Beifan ven'u). 1996. (2). C. 32-37 = 刘晓东. 渤海墓葬的类型与演变 // 北方文物. 1996. (2). C. 32-37. (In Chinese). https://doi.org/10.16422/j.cnki.1001-0483.1996.02.011.
34. Lyu Syaodun, Fu E. Predvaritel'noe izuchenie datirovki pogrebeniya San'linfen' i korrespondentsiya umershego v nem // Pamyatniki kul'tury severa (Beifan ven'u). 1992. (1). C. 30-35 = 刘晓东, 付晔. 试论三灵坟的年代与墓主人身份. 北方文物, 1992. (1). C. 30-35. https://doi.org/10.16422/j.cnki.1001-0483.1992.01.005.
35. Natsional'nyi kraevedcheskii muzei Yan'byan'skogo koreiskogo natsional'nogo avtonomnogo okruga. Kratkii otchet ob issledovanii mogil'nika bokhaiskoi printsessy Chzhen'-syao // Front sotsial'noi nauki (Shekhuei kesyue chzhan'syan'). 1982. (1). S. 174-180 = 延边朝鲜族自治州博物馆. 渤海贞孝公主墓发掘清理简报. 社会科学战线, 1982. (1). C. 174-180.
36. Otryad po rabote s kul'turnymi tsennostyami provintsii Tszilin', Muzei goroda Tszilin', Upravlenie kul'tury v uezde Yuntszi. Tretii sezon raskopok pamyatnika Yantun' v Yuntszi provintsii Tszilin' // Sbornik arkheologii (Kaogusyu tszikan': Izd-vo Kesyue). 1991. Vyp. 7. C. 23-50 = 吉林省文物工作队, 吉林市博物馆, 永吉县文化局. 吉林永吉杨屯遗址第三次发掘. 考古学集刊(七). 北京:科学出版社, 1991. C. 23-50.
37. Pen Shan'go, Van Lele. Sinekdokha pogrebal'nykh traditsii Bokhaya // Izuchenie raionirovannaya kul'tura (Diyui ven'khua yan'tszyu). 2021. (5). S. 86-91 = 彭善国, 王乐乐. 渤海葬俗举隅. 地域文化研究, 2021. (5). C. 86-91.
38. Fan Syuefen. Predvaritel'noe rassuzhdenie o gruppovykh pogrebeniyakh v Bokhae // Vestnik Yan'byanskogo universiteta (filosofiya i obshchestvennye nauki). 1991. (1). C. 73-78 = 方学凤. 试谈“渤海多人葬”. 延边大学学报 (哲学社会科学版), 1991. (1). C. 73-78.
39. Fen En'syue, Van Chun'yan'. Zagadka mokheskikh truposozhzhenii // Izuchenie arkheologii v pogranichnom raione. Pekin : Izd-vo Nauka (Kesyue chuban'she). 2013. Vyp. 14. S. 263-269 = 冯恩学, 王春燕. 靺鞨的火焚葬之谜. 边疆考古研究 (第14辑). 北京: 科学出版社, 2013, C. 263-269.
40. Khou Limin', Li Tsyan. Novoe izuchenie o Chzhen'lin' Bokhaya // Pamyatniki kul'tury severa (Beifan ven'u). 2002. (2). C. 32-36 = 侯莉闽, 李强. 渤海珍陵新探. 北方文物. 2002. (2). C. 32-36. https://doi.org/10.16422/j.cnki.1001-0483.2002.02.008.
41. Khua Yan. Issledovanie pogrebenii Bokhaya : dis… kand. ist. nauk. Chanchun' : Tszilin'skii universitet, 2015. 249 c. = 华阳. 渤海墓葬研究. 长春: 吉林大学博士学位毕业论文, 2015. 249 s.
42. Tszin' Taishun'. Neskol'ko problem v izuchenii bokhaiskikh pogrebenii // Arkheologiya (Kaogu). 1997. (2). C. 17-46 = 金太顺. 渤海墓葬研究中的几个问题 // 考古. 1997. (2). C. 17-46.
43. Tszin' Yufu. Dopolnenie k stat'e «Izuchenie stel bokhaiskoi printsessy Chzhen'-khuei» // Vestnik arkheologii (Kaogusyuebao). 1956. (6). C. 75-78 = 金毓黻: 关于«渤海贞惠公主墓碑研究»的补充. 考古学报. 1956. (6). C. 75-78.
44. Tszou Syuyui. Issledovanie i kommentirovanie teksta i predisloviya stely printsessy Chzhen'-syao // Sbornik materialov kul'turnykh tsennostei Yan'byan'. Yan'tszi : Izdvo naroda Yan'byan', 1983. S. 66-81 = 邹秀玉. 渤海贞孝公主墓志并序考释. 延边文物资料汇编. 延吉:延边人民出版社, 1983. C. 66-81.
45. Tsyan' Tsyan', Bao Shuguan, Lyu Syaodun. Izucheniya pogrebal'nykh traditsii bokhaiskikh nesovershennoletnikh // Pamyatniki kul'tury severa (Beifan ven'u). 2022. (2). C. 39-46 = 倩倩, 包曙光, 刘晓东. 渤海未成年人埋葬习俗研究. 北方文物. 2022 (2). C. 39-46. https://doi.org/10.16422/j.cnki.1001-0483.2022.02.008.
46. Chzhan Si"in. Kratkii otchet ob issledovanii fundamenta bokhaiskoi pagody Madida g. Khun'chun' // Issledovanie muzeya (Bouguan' yan'tszyu). 1984. (2). C. 91-94 = 张锡瑛. 珲春马滴达渤海塔基清理简报. 博物馆研究. 1984. (2). C. 91-94.
47. Chzhao Tszyun'tsze, Ma Tsinlin'. Datirovka raiona Lunkhai mogil'nika Luntoushan' v uezde Khelun i sootvetstvuyushchie voprosy. Sbornik tret'ei nauchnoi konferentsii molodykh uchenykh po arkheologii Kogure i Bokhaya. Vnutrennee izdanie. 2021. C. 202-228 = 赵俊杰, 马庆林. 和龙龙头山墓群龙海墓区的时代及相关问题, 第三届高句丽渤海研究青年学者工作坊学术研讨会会议论文集. 2021. C. 202-228.
48. Chzhi Shenyuan'. Predpologatel'noe obsuzhdenie o freske pogrebeniya printsessy Chzhen'-syao // Sbornik materialov kul'turnykh tsennostei Yan'byan'. Yan'tszi : Izd-vo naroda Yan'byan', 1983. S. 57-65 = 池升元. 浅谈渤海贞孝公主墓壁画. 延边文物资料汇编. 延吉: 延边人民出版社, 1983. C. 57-65.
49. Chzhen Yunchzhen'. Izuchenie bokhaiskikh pogrebenii // Sbornik pamyatnika kul'tury Kheiluntszyana (Kheiluntszyan ven'u tsunkan'). 1984. (2). C. 4-14 = 郑永振. 渤海墓葬研究. 黑龙江文物丛刊. 1984. (2). C. 4-14.
50. Chzhen Yunchzhen', Yan'Chanlu. O bokhaiskikh pogrebeniyakh// Izuchenie bokhaiskikh pogrebenii. Chanchun' : Izd-vo Tszilin' zhen'min' chuban'she, 2000. C. 90-159 = 郑永振, 严长录. 论渤海墓葬 // 渤海墓葬研究. 长春: 吉林人民出版社, 2000. C. 90-159.
51. Yan' Van'chzhan. Izuchenie stely bokhaiskoi printsessy Chzhen'-khuei // Vestnik arkheologii (Kaogu syuebao). 1956. (2). C. 69-73 = 阎万章. 渤海“贞惠公主墓碑”的研究. 考古学报. 1956. (2). C. 69-73.
52. Yan'byanskii muzei. Otchet ob arkheologicheskikh issledovaniyakh bokhaiskikh pogrebenii v Duntsine // Izuchenie bokhaiskikh pogrebenii. Chzhanchun : Izd-vo Tszilin' zhen'min' chuban'she, 2000. C. 251-288 = 延边博物馆. 东清渤海墓葬发掘报告. 渤海墓葬研究. 长春: 吉林人民出版社, 2000. C. 251-288.
Review
ISSN 2500-1566 (Online)